The Anonymous Widower

Defining The GOBlin Extension To Barking Riverside

Transport for London have published the results of their consultation on proposals to extend the for Gospel Oak to Barking Line (GOBlin) from Barking station to Barking Riverside.

To see the full report visit tfl.gov.uk/barking-riverside.

The main points are summarised in the next few sections.

Class 710 Trains

After the electrification of the GOBlin, services will be run using Class 710 trains, which although the line will be fully-electrified using overhead 25kVAC, will be the dual-voltage variant able to run on 750 VDC.

I would assume that this is so that the trains can go past Gospel Oak station to access parts of the North London Line and West London Line that have third-rail electrification and are shared with both London Underground and Southern Electric trains.

Bombardier have also told me, that all Aventra trains are wired so that an on-board energy storage capability can be installed.

When I rode the prototype for this IPEMU technology in public service between Manningtree and Harwich, it felt exactly like a standard Class 379 train and one of Bombardier’s engineers told me the battery range was upwards of fifty miles with a similar performance to the standard train.

In the remainder of this post, I will use Aventra IPEMU (Independently Powered Electric Multiple Unit) to indicate an Aventra Class 710 train with an on-board energy storage capability.

Because prospective routes for Aventra like the East London Line and Merseyrail run in longish tunnels, I would think it very likely that Aventras will be certified for tunnels like the Thames Tunnel or those under Liverpool.

Transport for London have certainly ordered a train, that doesn’t limit development of new routes linked to the GOBlin.

Lines At Barking Station

This map from carto.metro.free.fr shows the rail lines around Barking station.

Lines At Barking

Lines At Barking

The lines radiating from the station are as follows, taking them in a clockwise direction from the South West.

Three platforms will be used at Barking station for GOBlin services, which come into the station from Woodgrange Park in the West and from Barking Riverside in the South East.

  • Platform 1 which is the current terminus of the GOBlin will be retained and would remain available to Overground trains at Barking Station to aid service recovery during periods of disruption.
  • Platform 7 which is currently used by eastbound c2c trains via Rainham, will also be used by GOBlin trains going to Barking Riverside.
  • Platform 8 which is currently used by c2c trains from Rainham to Fenchurch Street, will also be used by GOBlin trains coming from Barking Riverside.

As can be seen on the map, there is a double-track flyover to connect Platforms 7 and 8, which are the two southernmost platforms to the GOBlin to the west.

The only platform and its associated connecting lines that doesn’t have any electrification is platform 1.

Changing Trains At Barking Station

The GOBlin services and c2c services via Rainham will share the island platform 7 and 8 at Barking, which could mean some easier step-free journeys for some passengers.

Plans exist for redevelopment at Barking station and I wonder if architects and planners can come up with a better layout for the station, that will become increasingly important as an interchange. Especially as the station is shared by three ambitious operators; London Overground, London Underground and c2c. All these operators have expansion and/or improvement plans for services through Barking.

Electrification of Platform 1 At Barking Station

No electrification work has happened on this platform until now and the platform could be electrified in the normal manner.

However, it may be more affordable to fit all the Class 710 trains with an IPEMU capability and run them in and out of the platform using the on-board energy storage.

The platform could also be electrified using London Underground’s system to create another bay platform for the District and Metropolitan Lines, if that was to be needed. This would not stop the platform being used by the dual-voltage Class 710 trains,

Obviously, the route planners and the accountants will decide.

Renwick Road Station

This map shows the layout of the extension.

Barking Riverside Extension

Barking Riverside Extension

Note now the new line curves away south after passing under Renwick Road. This Google Map shows the area.

Renwick Road Area

Renwick Road Area

One recommendation of the consultation is to install passive provision for a new station at Renwick Road, which eventually would make the extension a two-station branch.

The station is proposed to be a simple island platform design and TfL’s maps show it on the Western side of Renwick Road. There would appear to be plenty of space.

Barking To Renwick Road

On creating the required two lines between Barking and Renwick Road, the report doesn’t indicate, it’s anything other than a simple construction project.

Renwick Road to Barking Riverside

The line is proposed to curve off and over the rail lines and roads on a double-track viaduct, which is shown in blue on TfL’s map. The TfL report says this.

After passing under Renwick Road, the alignment would climb on a viaduct curving south towards Barking Riverside, crossing the Freight Terminal, westbound Tilbury lines and Choats Road.  The viaduct would then descend to pass under the existing high voltage power line south of Choats Road, before again rising and continuing  towards a station at Barking Riverside.

So it looks that the viaduct goes all the way to Barking Riverside station.

Barking Riverside Station

The proposed layout of the station is described in the TfL report.

The station would be designed to fit the look and feel expected of stations on the London Overground network, and would include the provision of step free access from street to platform and platform to train. Other features of the station would include:  a ground floor ticket hall, CCTV, help points, customer information systems and secure cycle parking.

The platform level would be on the upper floor as an extension of the viaduct structure. The station ticket hall would provide direct access to Renwick Road and the separation between the railway infrastructure and ground floor ticket hall would allow additional uses to be made of the space, such as: cash machines, cafe and retail opportunities. The station design would include cladding for weather protection, including a canopy to part of the platform to allow sheltered access to trains.

So it would appear the trains are on the upper floor above the station facilities, shops and cafes.

I think this is to ensure that once the trains have passed over the Tilbury Line to Rainham and the freight tunnel, they run fairly level into Barking Riverside station. It could also mean that if the line is extended to Abbey Wood station under the Thames, the track layout to achieve this is not too complicated.

This Google Map shows the location of the station in Barking Riverside.

Barking Riverside Station And The Thames

Barking Riverside Station And The Thames

Note.

  • TfL’s map shows the station is alongside Renwick Road, where it joins River Road.
  • It is perhaps a couple of hundred metres from the river.
  • The housing area of Thamesmead is opposite.
  • Trains could take a straight route to a possible Thames tunnel.

I think it all shows that the design of the station has been thought over long and hard.

Electrification Of The Barking Riverside Extension

The total length of the extension from Barking to Barking Riverside is 4 km., with just 1.5 km. of new line.

As with Platform 1 at Barking station, the Class 710 trains give the option of not-electrifying all or part of the extension.

Consider.

  • The performance of an Aventra IPEMU running on on-board energy storage, that had been charged before Renwick Road is such, that I believe it could easily handle the extension with a full train of passengers.
  • The viaduct can be built with provision for future electrification.
  • As mentioned in the TfL report, the line has to be carefully profiled to avoid existing power lines. An extension without electrification, would give extra clearance.
  • The Barking Riverside station design is simplified, if it is not electrified.
  • The area has overhead wires everywhere and a stylish viaduct without overhead wiring could have a less negative visual impact.
  • Are IPEMU trains running using on-board energy storage quieter than those using overhead wires?

But not electrifying the line from Renwick Road to Barking Riverside would reduce the complication and cost of the extension.

Intriguingly, the full TfL report only mentions overhead wires once, talking consistently about four car electric trains and a fully-electrified line.

Nothing in the TfL report precludes the use of Aventra IPEMUs to Barking Riverside and whether this route is chosen will depend on design and environmental issues, and the accountants.

Under The Thames To Thamesmead And Abbey Wood

It is planned to incorporate passive provision, so that the line can be continued in a tunnel under the River Thames.

Barking Riverside station appears to have been designed with several features to aid this continuation.

  • Trains could pass through the station on their way to or from the tunnel.
  • The route from the station to the tunnel would probably not need any sharp curves.
  • Barking, Barking Riverside and Renwick Road stations would probably be sufficient to handle passengers on the north side of the river.
  • There  appears to be nothing of any importance between the Barking Riverside station site and the Thames, so it should be easy to safeguard a route.
  • Barking Riverside station is elevated, so this potential energy could help to propel a train under the river.
  • A crude estimate says that from Barking Riverside station to the other side of the river is about two kilometres.

The engineers involved in the Barking Riverside extension have certainly made provision to extend the railway under the Thames.

This Google Map shows Thamesmead and the Thames.

Under The River

Under The River

Note River Road and Barking Riverside on the north bank of the river, Abbey Wood station with Crossrail and the North Kent Line in the South and Crossness to the East.

I don’t know the Thamesmead area well at all, and from these maps, I can’t work out whether a surface railway could be run to Abbey Wood station from the southern tunnel entrance.

However, a tunnel all the way with intermediate stops would surely be possible.

  • As London Underground have thought about extending the Jubilee Line to Thamesmead, I suspect that the area would be amenable to the right type of tunnel boring machine.
  • The tunnel could be bored under the A2041 if a direct route were to be chosen.
  • A trip from Barking to Abbey Wood and back is probably about twenty kilometres.
  • Aventra IPEMUs could handle the route with ease.
  • If Aventra IPEMUs used on-board energy storage in the tunnels, the tunnels could be built without electrification.

I believe that there is an affordable innovative solution to extending the Barking Riverside extension under the Thames.

I do question if an extension to Abbey Wood will be needed, as when Crossrail opens, it will be possible to travel from Barking to Abbey Wood with a single change at Whitechapel from the District/Metropolitan Lines to Crossrail.

Conclusion

As it should be, I think it is a well-thought plan.

As to whether the Class 710 trains will use a possible IPEMU capability, nothing is stated, but I believe the proposed design could be very IPEMU-friendly and using IPEMUs would be advantageous on cost, noise and visual grounds.

Their only downside is that they could get derided as battery trains.

I also have the feeling that if the extension does use the IPEMU capability of the trains, the extension will become a model for other extensions and branch lines all over the UK.

 

 

 

March 4, 2016 - Posted by | Transport | , , ,

3 Comments »

  1. […] I looked at the TfL report into the Barking Riverside Extension and wrote about it in Defining The GOBlin Extension To Barking Riverside, I came to the conclusion that there were advantages to having an extension without full […]

    Pingback by All Quiet On The IPEMU Front « The Anonymous Widower | March 7, 2016 | Reply

  2. […] Defining The GOBlin Extension To Barking Riverside, I traced how the extension will get to the new station. This is a map from the TfL report, which […]

    Pingback by In The Land Of The Giants « The Anonymous Widower | March 7, 2016 | Reply

  3. […] already feel, that one new line; the Gospel Oak to Barking Riverside Extension has been designed without […]

    Pingback by Electrification Of The Felixstowe Branch And Other Lines In East Anglia « The Anonymous Widower | March 19, 2016 | Reply


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.