The Anonymous Widower

Gatwick Makes A Pitch For The Third Runway

Canary Wharf tube station is all decked out in adverts for expanding Gatwick.

It’s certainly a tough fight between the two airports about which one gets developed.

On the ninth of October, I had a letter published in The Times, under the title, Plane or Train?

Sir, The closure of Richard Branson’s Little Red airline (News, Oct 7) comes at a time when people in their millions are rediscovering trains, raising a question over the attraction and viability of short-haul air services. Together with the introduction of aircraft that can carry up to a third more passengers, this leads me to wonder whether we need new runway capacity.

Effectively, it is a shorter reworking of some of the arguments in Hot Air Over London’s Airports.

To also stoke up the fire, Heathrow Hub were also advertising heavily in the papers at the weekend.

As I said in Hot Air Over London’s Airports, I quite like this proposal. This liking gets bigger every time I read about it.

One thing their reports and all the other proposals don’t talk about for obvious reasons, is the unpredictability of some of the world’s worst air accidents. Just read up on the circumstances that led to the Tenerife Airport Disaster.

For this and other reasons, I would leave the decisions to the professionals. And they will probably say that some proposals have a bigger safety margin than others!

But I still feel my last statement in the Hot Air post might be correct.

But I have this sneaking suspicion that no new runways will be built or extended and in twenty years time or so, we’ll wonder what all the fuss was about.

Passengers will just choose their airports with more care and airports will be competing with us with better and better facilities and more point-to-point flights.

But then some politician might want to add his name to a new London airport.

November 24, 2014 Posted by | Transport/Travel | , , , | 2 Comments

Heathrow and Gatwick Will Cost More

Surprise! Surprise! The BBC is reporting that the proposals for a new runway at either Heathrow or Gatwick will cost more!

The Airports Commission says a second runway at Gatwick would cost £2bn more than the bid suggests.

Two separate plans to expand Heathrow are predicted to cost £3-4bn more.

T’was, ever thus! The first real estimate of the cost of a large project is  inevitably more than the back-of-a-fag-packet estimate.

Only when the designers and project engineers work out how the project is to be realised do we get a figure for the actual cost. Usually, in construction projects, this figure can generally be relied upon.

But as I’ve believed for some time, I don’t think we’ll ever build a new runway in the South East.

November 11, 2014 Posted by | Transport/Travel | , , | Leave a comment

An Aerial Look At West Drayton Station

In my visit to West Drayton station, I also noted a railway line going away from the main line towards the North West.

West Drayton Station

West Drayton Station

In this aerial view you can clearly see it branching away at the station, which is marked by the red arrow. It then curves round to go under the Great Western Main Line in a Southerly direction, at the far left of the picture.

This is the Staines and West Drayton Railway and the northern section from West Drayton to Colnbrook is still used by freight trains. Some take fuel to a depot near Heathrow.

It seems to me over the last few years, there have been several proposals to improve the links from places like Reading and the West and Waterloo and South London, some of which pass through this area. But none seem to build on and improve this line.

We know that trains will be able to get from Reading and the West to Heathrow, but all projects to Waterloo and South London like Airtrack, seem to have foundered  until now.

On the other hand, when Crossrail and Thameslink are fully operational in 2019, it looks like the journey time between East Croydon and Heathrow, changing at Farringdon will be around an hour. Currently, it looks like it’s a couple of minutes over an hour and a half, with two changes. Fast times need a trip on the expensive Heathrow Express.

I think that the only certainty is that in the next ten years or so, Heathrow and Crossrail/Thameslink will have a tremendous influence on railways in the vicinity of West London.

 

 

October 20, 2014 Posted by | Transport/Travel | , , , | Leave a comment

Roll On Crossrail

I’ve recently been to Iceland for a few days holiday, which meant a trip to and from Heathrow.

For people like me in East London just to the North of the City, it is a boring and tedious journey.

Going out, I took the easy route for me, which is to take a 141 bus from virtually outside my house to Manor House station and then got the Piccadilly Line all the way to Heathrow. It gets you there but around thirty stops on the Underground isn’t quick at around an hour and a half.

Coming back, the flight was in a bit late and I decided to use Heathrow Express. My ticket cost me £13.80 with a Senior Railcard and is timed at 21:09, which as the Heathrow Express I got left Heathrow at 22:18 and arrived at Paddington at 22:36, says a lot for the speed of the Border Agency and the baggage handlers at the airport. From Paddington, I decided that as I was hungry and there is no good gluten-free restaurant at Paddington, that I would get a taxi. I got home just after 23:00, as although there were lots of taxis, the self loading cargo couldn’t get itself organised. As the taxi cost me £26, and although it might have been slightly quicker by about twenty minutes or so, each minute saved cost me a couple of pounds.

Next time, I’ll take the Underground.

In a few years time, I’ll probably use Crossrail. Heathrow to Whitechapel will take about 37 minutes according to their web site and from there to home is probably about 15 minutes now. So Crossrail should deliver a time of under an hour for a lot less money. Hopefully, it will be free as reports say that Freedom Passes will be able to be used to the Airport.

So on a brief look, it would appear that everybody in the City and East London will probably use Crossrail to get to Heathrow. Who in their right mind, would struggle to get to Paddington to get the Heathrow Express?

Incidentally, my taxi driver last night thought that Crossrail would be good for black cabs, as more people would use the train to get into London.

The one problem is that Terminal 5 at Heathrow is not on Crossrail. But looking at the various trains that are either are or will be connected to Heathrow and their routes, I would suspect that this will be rectified a few years after Crossrail opens.

There are various proposals that help to link Heathrow to the rail network.

The one that probably stands the highest chance of being built, is to link Terminal 5 to Reading to give rail access to the airport from the West of England and Wales. The BBC talks about it here.

If this one gets built would some Crossrail trains just go underneath Heathrow stopping at Heathrow Central, Terminal 4 and Terminal 5 in order before carrying on to Reading on the other side of the airport. At Reading, it could be a cross-platform interchange to fast trains to the west. Reading to Cardiff now takes just under a hundred minutes. When electrified and with new Class 801 trains, this could be reduced by about fifteen minutes or so.  So if you add the short hop from Reading to Heathrow, the journey to Heathrow from Cardiff could be well under two hours. If the Class 801 could get to Heathrow, obviously the journey would be quicker too!

July 16, 2014 Posted by | Transport/Travel | , , , | 2 Comments

Is Heathrow Connect Worth Keeping?

Today, I’ve gone to Heathrow using Heathrow Connect, ostensibly to take the pictures of the new Stockley Viaduct on the way in and the way out.

There seemed to be very few people going the whole way in either direction and at a price of £13.05 for the round trip with a Senior Railcard, it’s not cheap. But then if you went from Paddington to Heathrow by Underground, it’s only probably about twenty minutes slower.

Quite a few people were using the intermediate stations like Ealing Broadway and Hayes, but as these would not be on special expensive Heathrow prices, I suspect that they are not very profitable for the company.

When Crossrail is completed in 2019, Heathrow Connect is going to be dropped anyway as the new railway will call at all  Heathrow Connect stations.

One thing I didn’t like about it was the lengthy underground walks to the station from Terminal 1.

I hope Crossrail will be improving the interchange to the terminals, when it opens. But then Crossrail will not be serving Terminal 5 and a change of train will be required.

How customer-friendly is that?

As Terminal 5 is exclusively British Airways, they must be splitting blood.

May 29, 2014 Posted by | Transport/Travel | , , | Leave a comment

The Viaduct At Stockley Coming From Heathrow

I took these pictures coming back.

Such an impressive structure, is one of those that can’t be photographed too many times.

Note that coming back around midday the Heathrow Connect train was almost empty until it pickedup passengers in the Ealing area.

May 29, 2014 Posted by | Transport/Travel | , , , , , | 1 Comment

The Viaduct At Stockley Going To Heathrow

I mentioned in this post, that one of my reasons for using Heathrow Connect was to get pictures of the new viaduct at Stockley that carries the Heathrow branch of Crossrail over the Great Western Main Line.

The pictures were taken going to Heathrow.

It looks to be a very substantial viaduct. But then news reports are saving it is one of the largest bridges in the area since Brunel built the Great Western.

May 29, 2014 Posted by | Transport/Travel | , , , , , | 1 Comment

Restrictive Rules On Heathrow Connect And Express

I might go to look at Stockley Junction today and the best way would be to get Heathrow Connect to the airport and back.

So I checked up whether I can use my Senior Railcard on the train services. This section on the Heathrow Express gives the details about how you can. There is also this statement.

Yes, you can use a number of railcards on Heathrow Express to obtain discounted travel. To qualify you must purchase at the ticket office, not online or on board.

Obviously, they don’t agree with TfL’s policy of closing ticket offices.

They also don’t agree with the policy of the Gatwick Express as stated here.

Gatwick Express now accepts railcards online allowing you to make great savings on the already discounted online price if you have one of the following cards:

So Heathrow and Gatwick are out of step. Or you can always use the Piccadilly line, where the main problem is overcrowding.

It does appear though that according to Boris, as reported here, Crossrail will have a similar ticketing regime to the Underground.

So perhaps time will be up for the rip-off Heathrow rail services?

May 29, 2014 Posted by | Transport/Travel | , , , , , | Leave a comment

A Misunderstanding With Heathrow Connect

I was talking to an e-friend last night in California, who shares my interests of trains and large projects. He is getting on a bit and asked me to find an easy route from Heathrow to Barking, from where he can get a mini-cab to his sister’s. He’s coming in to Heathrow and asked me, if I knew of a step-free route.

Last time he took the Piccadilly line to Kings Cross from where he took the lifts up to the Metropolitan line for Barking. He managed it with ease, but wondered if Heathrow Express or Connect would be easier.

As I wanted to go to see the new Crossrail flyover at Stockley and I thought that Heathrow Connect would be a good camera platform to get a photo, as the train turned towards Heathrow, I told my e-friend, that I’d find out.

I checked last night and a web site told me, that my Freedom Pass could be used after 09:30 this morning.

Before I boarded the train, I asked the First Great Western man on the gate and said I’d be alright after 09:30. As it was 11:00, I boarded the train.

But I had to get off at Hayes and Harlington, as the rules seem to have changed.

I was not pleased, to say the least.

There’ll be an unholy row, if when Crossrail opens in a few years time, Freedom Passes can’t be used to the airport.

Update – I spoke to my friend late last night and he’ll be using the Piccadilly line with the Oyster card, he uses when he’s in London. He was also pleased to know, that probably from the end of this year, he’ll be able to use a contactless card as a ticket.

May 28, 2014 Posted by | Transport/Travel | , , , , | Leave a comment

The Row Over Heathrow Expansion

There is a real row going on in the letters column of The Times over expansion at Heathrow.

Akbar al-Baker started it by saying people get used to aircraft noise. What does a Qatari national know about the rights of the individual citizen?

But I think it’s all an argument, where the usual British attitude of do nothing and it will be all right on the night, may be the right one.

Various factors will come into play over the next few years, that will also make Heathrow expansion less important.

I have read somewhere that Heathrow passengers are more likely to be travelling for leisure rather than business reasons.

Tourists on the other hand, are more likely to plan a trip on matters of convenience and cost.

So if you live somewhere like Derby, you probably have two or three airports that are easier to get to than Heathrow, so if say that holiday in Florida is cheaper via East Midlands, why would you go to Heathrow?

Even where I live close to Central London, I probably have a multi-airport choice to make on any flight.

If nothing as this choice of flights and airports increases, it will take the pressure off the need for an extra runway in the South East.

The only people, who probably need to fly into Heathrow are those, who have a connection to make, like a businessman going from say San Francisco to Minsk. These passengers will still fly through Heathrow, but increasingly as London gets to be an even more desirable tourist destination, will a transfer passenger decide to spend the night in London before continuing their journey?

It all goes to show how I would never rely on any statistics given out by Heathrow.

So many travellers are held to Heathrow by all sorts of factors, that clever marketing by alternative modes of travel can erode. Ryanair for instance is thinking about going to the United States.

al-Baker also called for Heathrow to become a twenty-four hour airport. He would wouldn’t he, as one of the big beneficiaries of this would be the gulf airlines, as then they could schedule flights to and from London on a virtually turn-up-and-go basis to and from their own twenty-four hour airports.

The man is obviously a man with no experience of UK politics, as no British politician, would ever sanction a twenty-four hour airport in the UK, except possibly on an island in the middle of the North Sea.

But then he’s paddling his own interests as a Director of Heathrow and the CEO of Qatar Airways.

But there are also a couple of rather large elephants in the room; the next generation of super-jumbos and new and upgraded railways.

Airbus A380’s fly into Manchester and I suspect over the next few years, they and the next generation aircraft will fly into several airports in the UK, like Birmingham, Cardiff, Stansted, Liverpool and Edinburgh to create high-capacity point-to-point services, putting more pressure on Heathrow as the long haul airport of choice.

It could be thought that Crossrail would benefit Heathrow, as it will give a quick, affordable and easy route to Central London and South Essex. But it will also enable long-haul travellers to transfer with ease to London’s next three largest airports; Gatwick, Luton and Stansted, so a convenient flight out of London after a long overnight flight, might not be at another terminal at Heathrow, but at another airport after a restful lunch at Farringdon or some other Central London location.

In future HS2 might have an effect on Heathrow, as when fully developed, Manchester Airport will be just over an hour from Central London.

A twenty four hour three-runway airport at Heathrow will only benefit the airlines and probably those in the Gulf more than most.

But if we don’t create it, nothing serious will happen, as people will find more convenient and affordable ways of getting from A to B.

May 26, 2014 Posted by | Transport/Travel | , , , | Leave a comment