The Anonymous Widower

Okehampton Railway Return ‘Clear Reality’ After £40m Commitment In Budget

The title of this post, is the same as that of this article on the Okehampton Times.

This is the introductory paragraph.

The return of a regular passenger rail service to Okehampton is now a clear reality after £40m of funding to reinstate services was included in the Budget.

I am not surprised about this planned reopening, as much of the infrastructure is ready.

Okehampton already has a station, which is shown in this Google Map.

It looks as if there are tourist facilities at the station, where you can stay the night and hire bicycles.

The Dartmoor Railway connects the station to the Tarka Line at Coleford Junction.

  • The railway appears to be single track.
  • There is a single-platform station at Sampford Courtenay.
  • A Great Western Railway passenger service connects St. James Park and Okehampton stations on Summer Sundays.
  • This service also calls at Exeter Central, Exeter St. Davids and Ctediton stations.

In a section called Future Options for the Wikipedia entry for Okehampton station, finishes with this sentence.

Work started by Network Rail in 2020 on relaying and refurbishing the track between Coleford Junction and Okehampton with a plan to reopen the line to passengers during 2021.

It looks like a rail service could be made permanent and seven days per week, for an affordable budget.

The trains and those on the Tarka Line to Barnstaple are actually turned in a reversing siding at Exmouth Junction, which is shown in this Google Map.

Note.

  1. St. James Park station is to the West.
  2. Honiton station is to the East.
  3. The Avocet Line to Exmouth station goes South East at the bottom of the map.

I suspect that if more trains were reversed at Exmouth Junction, some work on track and signalling might be needed to be done.

This paragraph is taken from this article on the Moorlander, which is entitled Okehampton To Exeter Railway Line Secures More Than £40m Funding.

As The Moorlander has previously reported, the news means that Okehampton will become a ‘railhead’ for the hinterland and benefit three main markets; those wishing to visit the heritage station and Dartmoor, local people from Okehampton travelling to Exeter for work, leisure and education plus potential passengers wanting to connect with the train from West Devon, parts of Torridge and North Cornwall.

That seems all very sensible to me.

Could It Be Trialled As A Pop-Up Metro?

Could it be, that once the line is approved for opening, a service is run for a few months to test out, whether it would be financially viable?

It would be the classic test of the Pop-Up Metro concept, that has been proposed by Adrian Shooter of Vivarail, that I wrote about in Vivarail’s Plans For Zero-Emission Trains.

To be zero-emission, there would need to be one of Vivarail’s Fast Charge systems at Exmouth Junction, which could also charge trains for Barnstaple.

What would zero-emission battery trains serving Barnstaple and Okehampton so for passenger numbers?

Train operators discount the positive effects, these trains have on passengers.

Did Greater Anglia for instance, ever do any market research after the successful trial of the Class 379 BEMU train at Manningtree five years ago? I suspect not!

I estimate that to run the following pair of hourly services would take three trains for each.

  • St. James Park and Barnstaple via Exeter Central, Exeter St. Davids and Crediton.
  • St. James Park and Okehampton via Exeter Central, Exeter St. Davids and Crediton.

Two extra trains for a hot spare and one in maintenance would typically be added, to give a requirement of eight trains. As Great Western Railway already run the hourly service to Barnstaple, they would probably need another three trains for the Okehampton service.

I think there are two very sensible and affordable philosophies.

Refurbished Class 150 Trains

These pictures show a refurbishment of one of Great Western Railway‘s Class 150 trains.

 

Note.

  1. It is one of the finest train refurbishments, I have ever seen.
  2. As I rode one that had been to Barnstable, they can certainly handle the route.
  3. Great Western Railway have twenty of these trains.

What’s wrong with a fleet of these trains?

Vivarail Class 230 Trains

Battery-electric or diesel-electric versions of these Class 230 trains would be a possibility.

Note.

  1. I am not sure, if they could manage the climb to Barnstaple, but as they have have so many different power options, I suspect something is possible.
  2. If they are battery-electric, there could be a Fast Charge system at Exmouth Junction, where the trains turn back.
  3. Charging may also be needed at Barnstaple and Okehampton to nudge the trains down the hill.

Suppose the various improvements to track, signals and stations and providing charging cost half of the £40 million, that would leave £20 million to pay for the trains. In a cost comparison from October 2015, it is stated that lease costs of Class 230 trains are £7000 per car per month.

So if we call that £10000 to allow for inflation and the pandemic, that means that 8 x three-car trains will cost £2.88 million per year. There will obviously be maintenance and fuel and electricity costs to add. Let’s make the total £4 million per year.

So that would mean, that after spending £20 million on getting the infrastructure ready, the route could be run for five years as a trial.

Conclusion

Consider.

  • I feel that this line has been proposed for reopening, as it looks like there could be a good return on the investment.
  • The biggest problem would be finding three trains to run the service.
  • I suspect, it could also be implemented in a short period of time and perhaps open for Summer 2021.

This train service could be a prototype for many others in the UK.

 

 

March 6, 2021 - Posted by | Transport/Travel | , , , , , ,

6 Comments »

  1. So they run a summer Saturday service already yet it needs £40m to make it a more regular service. What do they need to spend that on?

    Comment by Nicholas Lewis | March 6, 2021 | Reply

  2. It appears to me, that Network Rail and other agencies in the UK usually get the track design correct. The Okehampton branch goes past to the quarry owned by Aggregate Industries. After that it could link to Plymouth to provide an alternative route to Cornwall.

    I would suggest that Network Rail want the line between Okehampton and Exeter to be able to handle enough trains, if at some date in the future trains between London and Plymouth had to go via Okehampton in cases of severe problems at Dawlish.

    So they might want to do things like.

    1. Improve Coleford Junction.

    2. Put in a passing loop.

    3. Lengthen platforms at Okehampton, so that longer trains can use it.

    4. Add a bus interchange at Okehampton.

    5. Make certain trains ro the quarry can get in and out.

    Hopefully, they’d make certain it was future proofed for a hundred years.

    Comment by AnonW | March 6, 2021 | Reply

  3. How on earth are we in a position where the seats look better on a 150 than on a 8xx service…..

    Comment by Matthew Hodgson Barratt | March 9, 2021 | Reply

  4. British Rail did some good seats and about three years ago, I took a friend to football at Ipswich in the days of the Mark 3 coaches and they felt it was a superb seat. Greater Anglia’s Stadler seats aren’t bad, but I suspect that BR designed very good frames, that fitted the British posterior.

    I suspect GWR decided, that it was possible to to turn a Class 150 train into something rather special.

    Have you ever ridden on one of South West Railway’s refurbished Class 455 trains? After the refurbishment some passengers thought they were new trains.

    There were some nice touches including a stainless steel cabinet to store the wheelchair ramp.

    We are very good at refurbishing trains in the UK.

    The trouble with the Hitachi trains, is that they were designed by the Treasury. The Scottish commuter trains are one of the best new suburban electric trains in the UK.

    Comment by AnonW | March 9, 2021 | Reply

    • BR’s PEP series of trains with low backs were pretty naff in comfort terms from the sprung seat units they replaced. Clearly they were miles better in many other aspects but the passenger has little interest in the technicalities of what they travelling in.

      Comment by Nicholas Lewis | March 9, 2021 | Reply

  5. […] Okehampton Railway Return ‘Clear Reality’ After £40m Commitment In Budget, I said more about this reopening project and I speculated that both Okehampton and Barnstaple […]

    Pingback by Dartmoor Rail Service Reopens This Year In Reversal Of Beeching Cuts « The Anonymous Widower | March 19, 2021 | Reply


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: