West Drayton Station – 22nd June 2202
I passed through West Drayton station today and took these pictures.
Note.
- The rebuilding of the station is almost finished.
- There are three platforms that can be used by the Elizabeth Line.
- The new Platform 5 is still to be completed
The station is fully step-free between street and platform, but not between train and platform.
Step-Free Provision On Elizabeth Line West Of Paddington
The stations may be step-free between street and platform, but West of Paddington, there does not appear to be step-free access between the platform and the train.
These pictures show a selection of stops.
Compare these steps of a few inches, with those I showed in Step-Free Access Between Train And Platform On The Elizabeth Line.
These pictures were taken between Woolwich and Paddington stations and show first class step-free access between train and platform.
The step-free access on the Western branch of the Elizabeth Line does not appear to be up to the standard expected of a world class railway.
Is The Current Arrangement Only Temporary?
I took these pictures at Padding Station today of a Class 345 train alongside Platform 10.
Note.
- There are large gaps.
- I had a chat with a station guy, who’d just unloaded two wheelchair passengers from the train using a ramp.
- He felt things could be improved.
- I feel that level access for the Elizabeth Line at Paddington is important.
But when the Elizabeth Line is fully connected, it will be connected to a series of Central London stations, including Paddington, that will have full step-free access between the train and the platform.
So the current arrangement will be improved dramatically in a few months.
The Visitor To London In A Wheel-Chair
The Central London section of the Elizabeth Line between Paddington and Whitechapel or Woolwich stations is step-free between street and train.
So a visitor to London in a wheel-chair might choose to stay in a hotel on this easy section of the Elizabeth Line to make the most of their stay.
But because of the lack of step-free access between train and platform outside of the Central London section, would they have trouble visiting places like Windsor, which would require a change of trains at Slough?
Would It Be Possible To Separate Elizabeth Line and Great Western Railway Services?
Consider.
- Great Western Railway services between Paddington and Didcot Parkway use the Elizabeth Line platforms at Ealing Broadway, Hayes and Harlington, West Drayton, Slough, Maidenhead, Twyford and Reading.
- In addition, some express trains stop at Slough and Ealing Broadway.
- There are also freight trains passing through.
It might be sensible to move the Paddington and Didcot Parkway service to the Elizabeth Line and adjust platform heights appropriately.
Westbound Elizabeth Line To Northbound Thameslink At Farringdon Station
This journey is the reverse of the one I did earlier today in Southbound Thameslink To Eastbound Elizabeth Line At Farringdon Station.
These pictures show my walk at Farringdon station.
Note.
- This route starts at the Western end of the Elizabeth Line platforms in Farringdon station.
- I took the escalator there to the top.
- I then walked to the left of the second bank of stairs and escalators.
- This took me directly on to the Northbound Thameslink platform.
This route also works if you’re going East on the Elizabeth Line and want to go North on Thameslink.
This second set of pictures show the walk in the reverse direction.
Interchange with the Northbound Thameslink platform is very easy in both directions, as most of the walk between platforms is done on the escalator.
Conclusion
There would appear to be an imbalance of quality between the connections between the Elizabeth Line and the two Thameslink platforms.
- Those going between the Elizabeth Line and the Northbound Thameslink platform will find it easy, as most of the route is on an escalator.
- On the other hand, those using the Southbound Thameslink platform at busy times could find it congested and slow.
I suspect that regular users of the station, will develop their own routes through the station.
Elizabeth Line To Northern Line At Moorgate Station
In Elizabeth Line – Moorgate Station – 27th May 2022, I took the recommended step-free route at Moorgate station between the Northern Line and the new entrance to the station.
It is a rather underwhelming and long route and this was my conclusion.
The rat-up-the-drainpipe route is acceptable to me, but I don’t feel the step-free route via the long tunnel will be acceptable for all those, who need to use it.
It’s just too long to walk for many!
Perhaps the addition of seats for a rest would help.
I wrote about the rat-up-the-drainpipe route to the surface, in Up From The Depths At Moorgate Station and in my view, if you can manage an escalator it is a better route between the Northern and Elizabeth Lines. Once at the surface, there are lifts and stairs to the new entrance, where there are escalators and a lift to the Elizabeth Line.
This morning, I was coming the other way, as I’d just off an Elizabeth Line train from Canary Wharf. These pictures show my route to the Northern Line.
Note.
- The signing at the start of the route, which is shown in the first picture is dreadful.
- I suspect, it leads to some of those in wheel-chairs ending up at the main escalators to Moorgate.
- The main route to the Northern Line includes a double set of stairs, but there is a by-pass lift.
- The connecting tunnel is overly long.
- At the end of the tunnel, there is a choice of a lift or long stairs.
- At least the tunnel is fully air-conditioned.
I took the lift and then used the escalator to the Northern City Line opposite.
Step-Free Access To The Northern City Line
It hasn’t been added.
Conclusion
Routes between the Northern and Elizabeth Lines at Moorgate need to be improved.
The Barbican Entrance To The Elizabeth Line – 10th June 2022
This series of pictures shows the route between the Westbound platform at Barbican station to the Elizabeth Line at Farringdon station.
Note.
- There is only a single lift between the Western end of the Westbound Platform 2/3 at Barbican station and the lobby between the two banks of escalators and inclined lifts, that give access to the Barbican end of Elizabeth Line platforms.
- Currently, there is no access between the Elizabeth Line and the Eastbound Platform 1 at Barbican station.
- If you lived in one of the towers of the Barbican estate, if might be a marginally shorter walk to walk along Platform 2/3 and up the stairs to the street.
When C and myself, lived in Cromwell Tower in the Barbican, in the 1970s, we must have walked that route with our three children hundreds of times. It really isn’t very different.
I have a few thoughts.
Is The Route Really For Passengers?
Consider.
- A journey, where you might need to use the route could be one like Barking and Heathrow.
- But you have a wide choice, as you could alight at Whitechapel, Liverpool Street, Moorgate, Farringdon and Ealing Broadway on the sub-surface lines and have step-free access to the Elizabeth Line.
- I suspect most customers will choose Whitechapel or Liverpool Street.
This picture shows the comprehensive control panel in the lift.
Could it be, that the main purpose of the lift is for staff access to hard to reach plant rooms?
Or perhaps it is designed to get a stretcher or wheelchair to the island platform at Barbican station?
Is The Connection Incomplete?
It could be that there is more work to do and the connection is incomplete.
There is a section, which is entitled Elizabeth Line, in the Wikipedia entry for Barbican station, where this is said.
Farringdon’s Barbican ticket hall for the Elizabeth line is just to the west of Barbican station along Long Lane. This construction involved significant changes at the western end of the station, including the demolition of the former signal box to construct a lift shaft from the Elizabeth line station to the westbound Underground platform only. The original plan of a new footbridge spanning the tracks to the eastbound platform was not proceeded with on the grounds of engineering difficulties. Work was anticipated to be completed in 2018, but was completed in May 2022.
It does look like, that the best that was possible was built.
First Order In For Revolutionary Modular Railway Footbridge
The title of this post, is the same as that of this article on New Civil Engineer.
Greater Anglia seem to have ordered the footbridge for Stowmarket station, without seeing a real one.
A prototype is also being installed at the former Widmerspool station on the Old Dalby Test Track.
I wrote about the proposed footbridge at Stowmarket in Stowmarket Station To Go Step-Free.
Elizabeth Line – Moorgate Station – 27th May 2022
I took these pictures as I walked between the Northern Line and the Moorgate entrance to the Liverpool Street station on the Elizabeth Line.
Note.
- There is a lift and stairs at the Northern Line end.
- I would estimate that the tunnel is about two hundred metres long.
- There are resting bars at intervals.
- There are two help points along the tunnel.
- There are two lifts to get to the Elizabeth Line ticket hall, at the other end.
I was able to walk it today, but when my damaged knee is playing up, I will not use this route.
However, the rat-up-the-drainpipe route to the surface, that I described in Up From The Depths At Moorgate Station is still available.
But this route is not wheel-chair and buggy friendly.
In this route, a single escalator is taken from the Northern Line platforms to the National Rail platforms, from where there is a double escalator to the ticket hall level.
Conclusion
The rat-up-the-drainpipe route is acceptable to me, but I don’t feel the step-free route via the long tunnel will be acceptable for all those, who need to use it.
It’s just too long to walk for many!
Perhaps the addition of seats for a rest would help.
Step-Free Access Between Train And Platform On The Elizabeth Line
Any new railway with new trains, should have step-free access train and platform.
I know that this has not always happened in the last few years, but how does the Elizabeth Line match up.
I’ve taken these pictures in the last couple of days.
On this evidence, it certainly seems that the access between train and platform is step-free, between at least Woolwich and Paddington stations.
Elizabeth Line – Whitechapel Station – 24th May 2022
I took these pictures at Whitechapel station on the Elizabeth Line.
Note.
- The step-free access between platform and train in two pictures.
- I wrote Whitechapel Station – 23rd August 2021, when the rest of the station opened.
- There are certainly a large amount of concrete panels.
- I have called Whitechapel station the Jewel In the East and now the Elizabeth Line has opened, I think we’ll see a lot of passengers changing trains at the station.
- Passengers reversing direction between the two Eastern branches of the Elizabeth Line, when they are going say between Woolwich and Ilford stations.
- The Hammersmith and City and the District Lines will give Elizabeth Line passengers access to the North and South of Central London.
- The Overground will give Elizabeth Line passengers access further out in North and South London.
Whitechapel station will effectively give easy passenger access to over another eighty stations, not on the Elizabeth Line.
Elizabeth Line – Farringdon Station – 24th May 2022
I took these pictures at the Barbican entrance to the Elizabeth Line at Farringdon station.
Note.
- The Barbican entrance is effectively at the Western end of Barbican tube station.
- There are two banks of escalators between street level and platform.
- Both banks of escalators incorporate an inclined lift.
There is also a lift connection between the landing between the two banks of escalators and the Westbound platform at Barbican station, which is shown in these pictures.
Note.
- It was a bit difficult to find.
- I am also not sure that there are stairs.
But it could be a quick shortcut for those with local knowledge.
I took these pictures at the Farringdon entrance to the Elizabeth Line at Farringdon station.
Farringdon station is a very extensive station.
The Anonymous Widower 