The Anonymous Widower

Cissé’s Stand On Wonga

Papiss Cissé is adamant he won’t wear a Wonga-branded shirt, as reported here in the Guardian.

I support his stand.

I would like to see a law, where all loan companies from the banks, through peer-to-peer lenders to the legal loan sharks, have to publish the amount of money they lend in various parts of the country.

That way we could see if shirt sponsorship was a good idea for lenders.

July 19, 2013 Posted by | Finance, Sport, Transport, World | , , , , , , | 1 Comment

A Wee Club In The North East

Not my words, but those of Sir Alex Ferguson about Newcastle United as reported on the BBC.

He has a point as what trophies have Newcastle won since Ipswich Town won the old First Division Championship in 1961-62.

One day though, Sir Alex will say something that really gets him into trouble.

December 28, 2012 Posted by | Sport | , , , | 1 Comment

Some Financial Ramblings About Wonga

I’ve never liked Wonga, ever since I saw a presentation of it at an Internet awards ceremony a few years ago.

There is an article in the Sunday Times today, which gives a few figures about the company. It apparently lent £375m last year and has made a debt provision of more than £66m. Or about 17.6 %.

That is a high figure and is totally out of line with good, well-run and profitable finance companies. I used to part-own one and our bad debt  ratio was if I remember correctly about five percent. Which was well below the industry average at the time.

I also have my own figures from Zopa, where I invest money to lend to third parties. My bad debt to invested money ratio  has never exceeded one percent.  But I do have a fairly conservative lending policy.

I have done extensive financial modelling in the area of finance companies and like to think, I know why well-run ones make a lot of money.

The first rule is to only lend to those with good credit ratings. Here, Zopa and Wonga are two very different animals.

Zopa creams the top of the market, acts like a normal finance company to borrowers and cuts its investors in on the deal. In fact, I wonder how many Zopa borrowers think of Zopa as a cheap source of finance with excellent terms and conditions?

Wonga on the other hand is a bottom feeder, targeting those with problems and might well look like a loan shark to many possible customers.

Other lenders like say Nationwide, Lloyds and the other reputable banks and finance companies are closer to Zopa, but probably not as much as they’d like to be.

The second rule is making sure that borrowers keep their payments up. Wonga don’t seem to be doing this judging by the bad debt ratio of 17.6 %, whereas Zopa is probably much better than the average for a reputable bank or finance company,judging by my experience. My ex-partner in the finance company feels that the Zopa figures are better than any he’s seen.

Wonga’s model is different to any other finance company. Banks and in effect, Zopa, get their money back over a period of time, typically measured in months or years. Whereas Wonga, probably gets it back in days, so the money goes round and round in the course of a year. Or it should do!

You might consider that Wonga is a money rental company, rather than a lender.  Even if it is one of last resort.

At present the Wonga model seems to be working, with a profit of about £26 on each transaction, of which the average size is £150. The Sunday Times doesn’t give the average length of each loan. Estimating what a typical reputable company might make on each deal, it looks like Wonga are really making quite a bit more money!

But there are two sides to every financial equation; money in and money out.

We ran our finance company on a very lean basis and if you are reputable and you get the business you need to grow the business as you want, then you don’t really need to spend too much money on things like advertising or promotion, as your customers do that for you. Even the banks don’t spend much on promoting their loan services! But they are uniquely placed to sell their loans with a big branch network.

Wonga are really spending it, judging by the adverts and the sponsorship you see.  Recently, it has been announced that they are pursuing a sponsorship deal at Newcastle United. Remember that the world of personal finance is littered with companies that thought they had a better model, but in fact didn’t. I’m old enough to have seen quite a few!

Wonga’s financial model seems to rely on putting your name in front of as many mugs as you can to carry out its bottom feeding.

If you compare Wonga with any reputable finance company, it would be unlikely that the latter would fall into trouble over its borrowers, as it would probably treat them fairly and respectfully. Using Zopa as an example, it only lends to those with good credit ratings, makes no charges to those, who don’t get loans and  generally charges a lower interest rate.

Wonga too, has already aroused the ire of some politicians like Stella Creasy over its policies and high interest rates. Politicians it should be said, need easy targets, like bankers with huge bonuses and payday lenders. Wonga in particular is a very easy target.

My financial modelling experience though does lead me to an important conclusion.

Wonga’s model will only generate profits, whilst there is a large pool of willing borrowers.  At present there are obviously enough, but as more and more suffer because of defaulting to Wonga, will the general public get the message that has been preached by the papers, like the Sun here and learn to use alternative sources of credit, like credit unions. Or in fact will they, just manage their finances better?

I gave the example of the Sun, as it is more likely to be the paper of choice of a possible Wonga borrower. On the other hand, there are some nice pieces about Wonga in the Guardian, the Telegraph, the Mail and the Mirror  It is also interesting to read some of the comments on a report of the Newcastle United sponsorship deal in the Newcastle Journal.

There is another big difference between the model Zopa and other reputable banks and finance companies use and that of Wonga.  The former rely heavily on personal recommendations from satisfied customers to get business.  Wonga would probably like to too, but with their high admitted default rate, the number of recommendations would be lower, especially if you’re being chased by them for the money.

So this all makes me think that at some time, Wonga will be unable to sustain the current growth. Especially, if legislation to limit their interest rates of over two thousand percent was passed by parliament.

I wonder whether they have already found the limit to growth, given the Newcastle United deal and the fact that the annoying bus adverts in London have reappeared in large numbers. After all what is a shirt sponsorship deal, but getting your company’s name in thousands of places on the street. If you are selling a quality product like say Emirates, Samsung, Standard Chartered or Waitrose, it doesn’t probably matter having thousands of football fans promoting your brand, but if you’re a payday lender, it might just be counter-productive  It would be very informative to read a learned paper on the effectiveness of shirt sponsorship.

October 7, 2012 Posted by | Finance, News | , , , , , | 4 Comments

There’s Only One F in Shefki

The news this morning is that one-time Ipswich favourite, Shefki Kuqi, has joined Newcastle until the end of the season.

February 10, 2011 Posted by | Sport | , , | Leave a comment

It’s Grim Up The North-East

Sunderland lost two-one at home to lowly Notts County, Middlesbrough lost by the same score to Burton Albion and then in the late match Newcastle lost three-one at Stevenage.  When I last looked at the map, Stevenage was in that hotbed of football, Hertfordshire.

Only a few footballers appear to have been born in the county and but they do include Dave Kitson, Kevin Phillips, Vinnie Jones, Jack Wilshere, Ian Walker, Iain Dowie, Rodney Marsh, Dean Ashton, John Radford and Ashley Young.  The last incidentally was in the same class at school in Stevenage as Lewis Hamilton and his brother, Lewis, was also on the bench today for Burton Albion.

So there might be some mild celebrations just to the north of the M25. But don’t insult the county by calling them soft Southerners or something similar or they’ll get Vinnie Jones to show you the errors of your ways.

January 8, 2011 Posted by | Sport | , , | 1 Comment

The Wembley Pitch

We get rather blase at Ipswich, as our pitch is often voted one of the best in the country.

I would have thought that the pitch at Newcastle would not be of a good standard, as the pitch is surrounded by high stands and Newcastle weather is not as good as that in London or Ipswich.

The Pitch at St. James' Park

This picture was taken around four o’oclock and you can see that it is mainly in shadow.  Surely, this isn’t good for grass!

Now I didn’t even walk on the pitch, but from my lofty place in the sky, it looked to be in good condition and the players didn’t seem to slip at all.

So if they can get it right in the more difficult circumstances at Newcastle, why can’t they get it right at Wembley?

April 26, 2010 Posted by | Sport | , , | Leave a comment

St. James’ Park, Newcastle

St. James’ Park is the home of Newcastle United and the reason I went north was to see Ipswich play for the last time this season.  I shall actually be away for the last home match.

Note the view from high in the stand over the city.  The Sage Gateshead, the Baltic Mill and some of the bridges can be clearly seen.

To me the most interesting thing about the game was Connor Wickham’s performance and his well-taken goal.  For the last few matches he’s been playing up-front on his own and he has scored quite a few goals.

I do hope that he both keeps this up and stays at Ipswich.

April 26, 2010 Posted by | Sport | , | Leave a comment

St. James’s Park

Newcastle United play at St. James’s Park in Newcastle.  Or they did?  But now they play at sportsdirect.com@St. James’s Park, as the stadium has been rebranded.

My first thought when I heard this was a very practical one.  In the days of fast sports news on a Saturday afternoon, when the call is something like, “Over to Alan at Old Trafford!”, would they really say “Over to Alan at sportsdirect.com@St. James’s Park”? No! They’d either use St. James’s Park or just Newcastle.

So Mike Ashley won’t be getting many bangs for his bug.

But he has spawned a lot of humour in the press.  Here’s the piece from The Times.

It puzzles me how a man, who obviously has talent to produce a multi-billion pound business, can make such a simple mistake.

November 5, 2009 Posted by | Sport | , | Leave a comment